The following familiar words of the Apostle Paul are quoted often at this time of year:
“… give thanks in all circumstances; for this is God’s will for you in Christ Jesus.” (I Thessalonians 5:18)
For many people, it is difficult to feel thankful this year even as we celebrate the national holiday of Thanksgiving. An atmosphere of fear and terror has gripped many cities as militarized ICE raids detain and arrest thousands of innocent people in the name of “law and order” and “securing the homeland.” It would be disingenuous and abusive to suggest that it is God’s will to be thankful for these awful circumstances.
Yet Paul does not call us to be thankful for all circumstances but in all circumstances. As I reflect on Paul’s words, I believe that we can be thankful even in this current circumstance, because Christ is with those who suffer and those who stand up with and for them. Even as the Trump administration expands their terror tactics, levels of nonviolent resistance expand as well. The resistance comes from many sources including but not limited to faith leaders, local government officials, community organizations, and students. Although the results of nonviolent resistance are rarely immediate, it exposes evil and presents a moral witness that can touch the national conscience and bring meaningful change. The Civil Rights Movement provides a precedent that testifies to the impact of nonviolent resistance on the conscience and policies of our nation. For this reason, we can confidently affirm and practice giving thanks even in this difficult time. The videos posted below are just a few examples of widespread nonviolent resistance for which we can give thanks in 2025. I invite you to take time to reflect on Paul’s words from Scripture in light of the videos.